Walk through any Indian city and you will pass a dozen different “classes” without ever seeing a boundary line. A software engineer and an auto driver might live two streets apart, shop at the same market, and send their children to different schools that sit within walking distance of each other. This is exactly what makes class so hard to study ethnographically. Neighbourhoods have edges. Ethnic groups have shared history. Caste, at least on paper, has clear rules of endogamy and hierarchy. Class has none of this. It slides. People move in and out of it within a single lifetime, and sometimes within a single generation. So how do anthropologists, who are trained to study bounded communities with observable rituals and shared spaces, actually get a grip on something as slippery as urban class?
Table of Contents
- Why class refuses to sit still
- Occupation as the way in
- What holds a status community together
- Ethnographies of marginal occupational groups
- When joblessness becomes a community
- Rickshaw pullers as a status community
- Domestic workers, hawkers, and other status communities
- Caste, occupation, and status communities in urban India
- What do you think?
Why class refuses to sit still
Neighbourhoods are tied to a patch of land. Ethnic groups carry a shared history and often a shared language or region of origin. Caste groups, at least in the traditional Indian framework, are fixed by birth and governed by rules about who can marry whom and eat with whom. Class shares none of these anchors. A person can be born into a working-class household, get an education, take a white-collar job, and effectively exit their class of origin without changing their name, religion, or place of birth.
This mobility is precisely what troubled early urban anthropologists. If you cannot point to a fixed territory, a shared genealogy, or a closed marriage circle, what exactly are you studying when you study “class”? A neighbourhood ethnography can be done by living in one locality. A caste ethnography can be done by tracing kinship networks. But class cuts across localities and kinship lines, which means the usual toolkit of participant observation does not map onto it in any obvious way.
Occupation as the way in
Faced with this problem, ethnographers found a workaround: instead of chasing class as an abstract economic category, they anchored their fieldwork in occupation. This made sense because almost every serious definition of class treats occupation as a core ingredient, alongside income and education. Occupation, unlike income or lifestyle, is something you can actually observe. You can watch people go to work, see where they gather, and note who they talk to on the job.
The sociologist Holger Stub, writing in 1972, gave this approach a name: the status community. He proposed it as an alternative to conventional class analysis, one that was better suited to fast-moving urban settings. Rather than asking “which class does this person belong to,” the status community approach asks “which occupational group shapes this person’s daily interactions, self-image, and social circle.” This shift in the question turned out to be far more useful for fieldwork.
What holds a status community together
A status community is built around a single occupation or a cluster of related occupations. Its members share roughly equal standing and similar economic interests, which naturally pulls their lifestyles into alignment. They interact with each other far more than with outsiders, simply because their working hours, workplaces, and daily routines overlap. Over time, these interactions produce genuine primary ties, the kind of close, personal bonds usually associated with family or old friendship groups.
Crucially, a status community also draws boundaries. Members develop a sense of “us” versus people outside the occupation, even when they share the same neighbourhood or even the same caste background as outsiders. This boundary-drawing is what makes the group ethnographically visible. You can find its edges, its gathering points, and its internal hierarchy, even though the “class” it represents has no fixed territory of its own.
Ethnographies of marginal occupational groups
Anthropologists have gravitated toward marginal and informal occupations when applying this framework, partly because these groups are easy to locate and partly because their precarious position sharpens group solidarity. Several classic studies illustrate how occupation, more than income or education, becomes the organising principle of urban social life.
When joblessness becomes a community
Peter Gutkind’s research among unemployed people in Lagos and Nairobi produced a counterintuitive finding: even the absence of a job could generate a status community. His fieldwork, described in his study of the social organisation of the unemployed in these two African cities, showed that kinship and tribal loyalties often took a back seat to bonds formed around shared economic hardship. Employment exchanges, meant to be transactional spaces for finding work, turned into informal gathering places where the unemployed swapped stories, pooled information, and built a recognisable, bounded community defined entirely by their shared lack of steady work.
Rickshaw pullers as a status community
Harold Gould’s fieldwork among cycle rickshaw pullers in Lucknow remains one of the most cited examples of the status community approach. His study of the social organisation of this occupational category treated the rickshaw pullers not as a stray collection of individuals but as a distinct urban group with its own internal structure. The nature of the work itself created constant opportunities for interaction: pullers wait together at stands, cross paths repeatedly through the day, and depend on each other for information about fares, routes, and trouble spots. This produced a tightly closed group, often supplementing their income through informal or borderline-legal side activities, which in turn strengthened their mutual dependence and code of secrecy. Because rickshaw pullers move constantly through the city, anthropologists also valued them as informants who understood urban geography, and its informal rules, better than almost anyone else.
Domestic workers, hawkers, and other status communities
Female domestic workers show a similar pattern. Working in isolated households scattered across a city, they nonetheless develop strong solidarity through their shared working conditions and economic vulnerability, often meeting at parks, water points, or transit stops to exchange information about employers and wages. This solidarity has, in recent years, translated into organised advocacy: domestic workers’ unions and platforms such as the National Platform for Domestic Workers now negotiate directly with government on issues like minimum wages and written contracts, a level of collective organisation that would be hard to imagine for a group defined only by neighbourhood or caste.
Street hawkers follow a comparable trajectory. William McGee’s research on Hong Kong’s street hawkers compared their irregular, unregulated work with formal employment, finding that despite the instability, hawkers formed unions and syndicates that gave their status community real bargaining power. India offers a close parallel: street vendors across the country organised into federations that deliberately avoided formal party politics, choosing associational strength over trade-union entanglement, and eventually helped shape national legislation protecting their livelihoods.
Sex workers show perhaps the sharpest example of status-community cohesion, precisely because their occupation carries high legal and social risk. Facing criminalisation of associated activities and persistent stigma, sex workers in India have built collectives such as the National Network of Sex Workers, which documents members’ experiences and pushes back against discrimination at local, national, and international levels. The intensity of external pressure they face has, paradoxically, produced one of the more tightly bound status communities anthropologists have studied.
Caste, occupation, and status communities in urban India
India adds another layer to this picture because occupation and caste have historically been fused. Under the traditional varna and jati framework, specific castes were assigned specific occupations, and certain occupations, particularly those involving leather, waste, or the disposal of the dead, were branded ritually polluting. This is where the notions of purity and pollution that structured untouchability came from: an entire hierarchy built not just on birth but on the “impurity” attached to particular kinds of work.
Cities loosened this rigid link considerably. Urban residents can, in principle, take up any occupation regardless of caste background. Yet in practice, some communities have stayed close to their traditional trades, not out of obligation but because they found economic advantage in it. The Jatavs of Agra are the textbook case. Historically classified as untouchable leatherworkers, many Jatav families remained in the leather trade even as the city industrialised, eventually building substantial shoe and leather businesses. The anthropologist Owen Lynch documented this closely, having lived among the Jatavs of Agra for sixteen months during the early 1960s to study exactly this transformation.
What makes the Jatav case so useful for this discussion is that it collapses two categories that ethnographers usually keep separate. The Jatavs function simultaneously as an ethnic or caste group, bound by shared descent and historical discrimination, and as a status community, bound by shared occupation and economic interest. Their leather business success gave them not just money but organised political weight, which they have used to press for greater recognition and rights. Few groups illustrate as clearly how caste and class can overlap in a single urban population, even while remaining conceptually distinct.
What do you think?
Reflect on this: If you were designing an ethnographic study of a modern occupational group, say delivery riders or call centre workers, what boundaries would you expect to find holding that status community together? And do you think economic mobility today is loosening the old caste-occupation link the way it did for the Jatavs, or reinforcing it in new forms?
References
- https://scholarexchange.furman.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1002&context=ant-publications
- https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Lucknow-Rickshawallas:-The-Social-Organization-of-Gould/905fdca335ad567a7703c6a9bf52479a4f74f3b2
- https://www.ilo.org/meetings-and-events/ilo-hosts-national-consultation-promoting-decent-work-domestic-workers
- https://connect.fes.de/people/street-vendors-in-india-from-invisibility-to-centre-stage
- https://sdg.iisd.org/commentary/guest-articles/invisible-and-uncounted-sex-workers-in-india/
- https://www.epw.in/engage/article/untouchability-india-reading-list
- https://www.epw.in/journal/2013/23/letters/remembering-owen-lynch.html
Leave a Reply